The top nine spots on the AppDynamics/Mobile Strategies 360 3G Index stayed the same for the week ending April 3, compared to the previous week ending March 27. This is remarkable consistency, says Peter Kacandes, senior product marketing manager, mobile, web and synthetics, for AppDynamics.

And yet, five of the top nine companies on the 4G index shuffled around. Why would mobile sites in one network shuffle around but hold steady in a different network? Well, it’s complicated, Kacandes says.

First, the index is dependent on the relative positions of the other companies, Kacandes says. For example, on the 3G index, J.Crew Group Inc.’s mobile site home page performance ranking remained the same at No. 13 from week to week. On 4G, J. Crew rose four spots to No. 8 after its speed index improved by 0.5 seconds.

“In 3G, J. Crew also had an improvement in Speed Index (a 0.7 second decrease), but when compared to everybody else, they still wound up in the same spot,” Kacandes says. “In 4G, the change was enough to move them relative to the other companies.”

The Speed Index, which ultimately determines a mobile site’s ranking on the index of 30 companies’ mobile site performance, is a complicated metric, Kacandes says. It looks at the percent of content on a mobile home page that is displayed and how quickly, and compares those ratios over the course of the week.


“There is a very complex interaction between the size of different assets and how long it takes them to load over different network speeds. It’s not a purely linear scaling,” Kacandes says.

“The Speed Index is useful because it allows you to compare the perceived performance from the user perspective for different sites that may have very different page weights and page metrics, such as visually complete and start render,” he adds. Visually complete time is the time it takes a web browser to finish drawing the visual elements on the home page, and start render is the time it takes for the web browser to start drawing the elements on the home page.

Kacandes also notes that while the top nine spots on the 4G index weren’t exactly the same compared to the previous week, they were fairly consistent.

“Morton’s held the top spot, Gilt fell two spots, Etsy and Cheesecake moved up one spot,” he says. “Costco, Illinois, Budget were all in the same positions.”


In the middle of the pack, Nordstrom Inc. dropped four spots on 3G to No. 26 from No. 22 the previous week. A Nordstrom spokesman declined to comment.

Also, moved up three spots on 3G to No. 23 from No. 26 the previous week, despite a 500-kilobyte increase in the home page weight and a 4.8-second increase in the visually complete time. Start render time also decreased by 0.6 seconds, Kacandes says.

Shiela Jones, development manager at Fathead LLC, attributes the increase in index rank to the web-only sports and entertainment decal retailer optimizing images and JavaScript on its mobile site home page.

“We have compressed the image files used for our carousel on the home page, utilizing less complex images while retaining the quality,” Jones says.


The exclusive AppDynamics/Mobile Strategies 360 Index tracks key mobile site metrics across a range of sites to calculate a weekly average Speed Score on both 3G and 4G mobile carrier networks. The index represents a snapshot of mobile site performance across industries, including retailers such as, insurance companies such as and restaurants such as

AppDynamics each week measures performance metrics of both 3G and 4G networks for each of the 30 sites in the index to determine each site’s Speed Score.

They include:


First render: The time, (in seconds) it takes until the web browser starts drawing the visual elements of a home page.

Visually complete: The time (in seconds) it takes until the web browser has completed drawing the visual elements of a home page.

Number of elements loaded: The number of resources loaded by a home page.

Complete load: The size of the home page when all data is loaded (in megabytes).


Using these metrics, the index calculates the Speed Score. The Speed Score is a ratio that rewards businesses for displaying more visual content on the mobile home page earlier rather than later. The earlier a mobile site home page looks complete to a consumer, the better the mobile experience for the visitor, even if a few remaining elements are displayed later. A site with a higher ratio of content displayed earlier will have a better Speed Score than a site with the same visually complete time but a longer first render time.

For example, site A may have a visually complete home page load time of three seconds, loading 90% of its content in the first second and the remaining 10% in seconds two and three. Site B may have the same three-second visually complete time, but present zero content in the first two seconds and 100% in the third second. The sites have identical visually complete times, but Site A will be perceived as much faster, and will earn a better Speed Score as a result.

The index is accompanied by a chart on that is refreshed weekly to illustrate how each mobile site performs as well as index averages. Click here to access the performance chart for the week ending April 3.

Subscribe Today to Mobile Strategies 360 and receive exclusive data. Not only will you get the latest information on the rapidly changing mobile industry, you will also receive Mobile Market Insights a free monthly overview on the market. These fact sheets are filled with data and statistics to help you identify opportunities and get a jump on the competition. Mobile Market Insights is available only to Mobile Strategies 360 subscribers. Once you enter your free subscription, click on the link for your free download.


Be sure to follow us on Twitter and LinkedIn and be the first to know when new Mobile Strategies 360 content is published.